By Dr. Manu Sharma, DMD, board certified orthodontist | October 2026
Choosing who will straighten your teeth, or your child's, is a bigger decision than it first appears. Orthodontic treatment usually lasts a year or more, changes how teeth fit together for life, and depends heavily on the judgment of the person planning it. Yet many families choose based on a friend's recommendation, an ad, or the lowest quote.
Those are reasonable starting points, but they are not enough. This guide explains the difference between an orthodontist and a dentist who offers braces, what board certification really means, and the questions that will tell you the most about any practice, including ours.
Key Takeaways
- Orthodontists complete two to three years of full time specialty training after dental school.
- According to the AAO, only about 6 percent of dentists are orthodontists.
- Board certification by the American Board of Orthodontics is voluntary and involves written and clinical exams; you can verify it online.
- A good consultation includes complete records, a clear diagnosis, and more than one option when more than one would work.
- Ask what the fee includes, how emergencies are handled, and how results are kept stable afterward.
Orthodontist or Dentist Who Offers Braces?
Every orthodontist is a dentist, but not every dentist who offers braces or aligners is an orthodontist. The American Association of Orthodontists points out that placing braces or aligners does not, by itself, make someone an orthodontist.
Here is the difference in training. After four years of dental school, an orthodontist completes an accredited specialty residency lasting about 24 to 36 months. The AAO describes these programs as accredited by the Commission on Dental Accreditation and involving roughly 3,700 hours of training devoted to moving teeth and guiding jaw growth. In total, orthodontists complete more than a decade of higher education. Only appropriately trained orthodontists can be members of the AAO.
Why that matters to you. General dentists provide essential care, and many do excellent work. Orthodontics is a specialty, though, with its own body of knowledge: growth and development, biomechanics, the relationship between the jaws and the face, and managing complex cases. That focused training is what allows an orthodontist to spot when a problem is skeletal rather than dental, when to treat early and when to wait, and when a case needs a surgeon or another specialist.
You do not need a referral from your dentist to see an orthodontist. You can book directly.
What Board Certification Means
Board certification goes one step further. The American Board of Orthodontics is the certifying board for the specialty, and certification is voluntary. Orthodontists who pursue it must pass peer developed written and clinical examinations, including presenting their own treated cases with complete records, and must continue to demonstrate their knowledge over time.
In practical terms, the clinical exam requires detailed documentation of real cases: before and after records, X ray tracings, and superimpositions that show exactly what changed during treatment. I describe that process in our article on cephalometric analysis. Certification is not a guarantee of any particular result, but it does reflect a commitment to the standards of the specialty and to ongoing self assessment.
How to check. The ABO offers an online Orthodontist Locator where you can confirm whether a provider is board certified. It takes less than a minute.
10 Questions Worth Asking at a Consultation
Most practices offer a free or low cost first visit. Use it. These questions will tell you far more than an online rating.
1. Are you an orthodontist, and are you board certified?
Simple, direct, and completely reasonable to ask. A confident practice will be glad you did.
2. What records will you take before recommending treatment?
A proper diagnosis usually includes photographs, a digital scan or models, and X rays, typically a panoramic image and a side profile (cephalometric) X ray for comprehensive cases. Be cautious if someone recommends a specific treatment before looking beneath the gums. Our first visit page explains what each record shows.
3. Is my problem in the teeth, the jaws, or both?
This is the most important question in orthodontics. Two bites that look identical in the mirror can have very different causes, and they need different treatment.
4. What are all of my options, including doing nothing or waiting?
Most cases can be treated more than one way. A good orthodontist explains the trade offs between braces, Invisalign, and other approaches, and tells you honestly when waiting is the better plan.
5. For a child, why now?
The AAO recommends a first orthodontic check by about age 7, but most children seen at that age do not need treatment yet. If early treatment is recommended, you should hear a clear reason, such as a crossbite, a significant underbite, or severe crowding that early action can improve. Our early orthodontic evaluation page explains when early treatment helps.
6. How long will treatment take, and what could change that?
Expect a range rather than a promise, along with an explanation of what affects it: growth, cooperation, and how the teeth respond.
7. What exactly does the fee include?
Ask whether records, adjustments, emergency visits, and retainers are included, and how insurance and payment plans apply. Our guide to what braces cost lists the details to compare.
8. Who will I see at each visit?
In some offices the orthodontist sees you at every appointment. In others, assistants handle routine steps under the orthodontist's supervision. Both can work well, but you should know who is checking your progress and making decisions.
9. What happens if something breaks?
Brackets come loose and wires shift. Ask how the office handles these issues and how quickly they can see you. Our article on orthodontic emergencies covers what is urgent and what can wait.
10. How will you keep my results stable?
Teeth tend to drift after treatment. A thoughtful retention plan is part of good orthodontics, not an afterthought. Ask what type of retainer you will receive and what replacements cost. Our article on retainers after braces explains why this matters so much.
Bring your questions
At our office, Dr. Sharma answers every one of them at a free consultation, with complete records and a written estimate.
Signs a Practice Is a Good Fit
Beyond credentials, pay attention to how the visit feels:
- You understand your diagnosis. You leave knowing what the problem is, in plain language, and why the recommended plan addresses it.
- You are not rushed or pressured. A good practice gives you time to decide and is comfortable with "let me think about it."
- Your questions are welcomed. No question about cost, timing, or alternatives should feel unwelcome.
- The plan fits your life. Your schedule, budget, and preferences should shape the options presented.
- Communication is clear. You know how to reach the office, how insurance is handled, and what happens next.
Red Flags to Watch For
- A treatment recommendation without X rays or a proper exam.
- One option for everyone. If every patient gets the same appliance, the plan may be fitting the practice rather than the patient.
- Pressure to sign the same day, especially with limited time "discounts."
- Vague answers about fees or what happens if treatment runs long.
- Mail order or app based treatment without in person supervision. Moving teeth is a medical process, and problems like gum disease, decay, or jaw issues need to be identified and monitored.
Should You Get a Second Opinion?
Yes, if you are unsure. Orthodontics involves judgment, and it is perfectly normal to see two practices before deciding. If two orthodontists recommend different approaches, ask each to explain their reasoning. Often both plans are reasonable, and the difference comes down to trade offs you can weigh.
Local Considerations for Tri City Families
For families in Newark, Fremont, and Union City, convenience matters over a treatment that may involve a visit every six to ten weeks for a year or more. Consider the location relative to school and work, appointment availability, and parking. Our office is at Newpark Mall in Newark, close to Interstate 880, which makes it an easy drive from most of Fremont and Union City.
The Tri City area is also a remarkably diverse community. Facial proportions and what looks natural vary between people of different backgrounds, so ask how your orthodontist accounts for that when planning how your profile and smile will look at the end of treatment.
Why Specialty Training Matters Most in Complex Cases
For simple alignment of a few teeth, the differences between providers may seem small. They become much larger when a case involves growth, the jaws, or several problems at once. Consider a few common situations:
- A child with a developing underbite. Deciding whether to treat early, which appliance to use, and how long to monitor afterward depends on understanding facial growth patterns. Our article on underbite treatment explains why timing is so important.
- A crossbite with a jaw shift. Recognizing that the lower jaw slides sideways on closing, and treating the narrow upper jaw that causes it, can influence how the face develops. See our guide to crossbites in children.
- An adult with a skeletal bite problem. Knowing when tooth movement alone can produce a stable, attractive result, and when a surgical consultation is the honest recommendation, requires experience with both outcomes.
- Impacted or missing teeth. Coordinating with oral surgeons, periodontists, and general dentists is part of everyday orthodontic work.
In each case, the plan made at the start shapes everything that follows. That is where specialty training and experience pay off most.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a referral to see an orthodontist?
No. You can book directly with an orthodontist. Your dentist may suggest an evaluation, but a referral is not required.
What is the difference between an orthodontist and a board certified orthodontist?
All orthodontists complete specialty residency training after dental school. Board certification by the American Board of Orthodontics is a voluntary extra step that requires passing written and clinical examinations and maintaining certification over time.
How can I check if an orthodontist is board certified?
Use the American Board of Orthodontics Orthodontist Locator on the ABO website to search by name or location.
At what age should my child first see an orthodontist?
The AAO recommends a first check by about age 7. Most children do not need treatment then, but an early look helps catch problems that are easier to guide while a child is growing.
Is it okay to get a second opinion?
Absolutely. Any good orthodontist expects and respects it. Ask each practice to explain the reasoning behind its plan.
Meet Our Team
If you are comparing orthodontists, we would be glad to be one of the practices you visit. You can learn about Dr. Manu Sharma's training and certification, meet our staff, or start with our new patient page.
See if we are the right fit
Book a free consultation, bring your questions, and leave with a clear diagnosis and a written estimate.
This article is general educational information and is not a substitute for an in person evaluation by a licensed orthodontist.
References
- American Association of Orthodontists. Understanding orthodontics: what is an orthodontist?
- American Association of Orthodontists. How to know if a dentist is also an orthodontist.
- American Board of Orthodontics. Information for patients and Orthodontist Locator.
- American Board of Orthodontics. Case record requirements for the clinical examination.
- American Association of Orthodontists. How much do braces cost? Financing options for orthodontic treatment.
